ma.gnolia thoughts

So, I went to the Future of Web Apps summit in London this week. I may have a full post about that soon—but this isn’t it.

During a presentation by Tara Hunt and Chris Messina (Fostering Online Communities), Chris showed a cool new feature of ma.gnolia that really piqued my interest. Despite being a long-time del.icio.us user (my first del.icio.us bookmark was on 12/31/2003), I thought I’d try ma.gnolia (again) with a fresh perspective and an open mind.

Here are a few of my thoughts on the site and app after using it for just a few minutes:

  1. Using OpenID – Good job :)
  2. They need help with their “Blank state” pages (pages that don’t have data yet). When I first signed in, and didn’t have any bookmarks, friends or groups, my main page was a bit bare. Blank slates are a great opportunity to show the user either what the page could look like when they’re really rockin’ or, a call to action on how to start rockin’. 37Signals has lots to say about this subject.
  3. The Dashboard widget is neat. A few complaints about it:
    • it doesn’t allow me to sign in with OpenID (which the main site does)
    • just like their popups, the tag suggestions are based only off MY bookmarks, not other peoples. This is something that may seem small, but by showing what others have tagged a site with (and even helping you type them), you can amplify a common vocabulary.
    • It puts the contents of my clipboard in the description portion… yuch!
  4. My import from del.icio.us still hasn’t happened yet! What gives?
  5. It’s slow. Could be bad timing on my part, or my sketchy WiFi in London, but it’s a lot slower than del.icio.us at this moment. I’m going to reserve judgement on that for now.
  6. It’s NOT just a pretty a del.icio.us clone (anymore) – SHOCKING! I held this belief until talking to Chris about the site, and actually playing with it myself. I now see that I was unfairly judging it (I do think they have an image problem though). What it gives you above and beyond del.icio.us are the community aspects of something like Flickr. A really neat bit is the “give thanks” (which is the feature I alluded to before)
  7. Their pagination really stinks… in a few places, each “page” is 5 or so items… What.The.Hell!
  8. Commas instead of spaces for tagging. This is 100% a personal preference, but I like spaces!

I think they’re doing some good stuff—I’m not ready to throw out del.icio.us just yet, but I will be posting to both services until one of them is less compelling to me.

2 thoughts on “ma.gnolia thoughts”

  1. I tried ma.gnolia for a week or so a while back and though there is a community aspect to it, unless you are compelled to spend time browsing and interacting with that community, del.icio.us works much more efficiently.

    To me it makes more sense to post community-like items on a blog or on facebook where there is already a social network in place (I’ve actually only in the last few weeks been posting items to facebook and it’s really been great since everyone is on it). For links I want to archive and reference, del.icio.us is much better at providing that service (also, the interface is MUCH cleaner).

    If you want to spend time in a bookmarking network, go to ma.gnolia. If you want a streamlined and efficient place to store bookmarks to reference in the future, use del.icio.us.

    Ma.gnolia is like a group link blog whereas del.icio.us is an engine for saving references.

  2. Well said Zach! I do like the community aspect, so I’m totally sticking with it for now. It’s been more then a week, and I’m still digging it.

Comments are closed.